International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies (IFRC) International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies (IFRC)
Search :

News
News Home
News Stories
Press Releases
Speeches
Opinion Pieces
Audio & Video
Clarifying the facts: helping illegal migrants does not encourage irregular migration
23 May 2007
Marie-Françoise Borel
Migration is no longer a series of population movements, but a constant flow of people across borders, all over the world. According to the International Organization for Migration (IOM) more people are on the move now than at any other time in human history. Today, there are nearly 200 million people living outside their place of birth, which is about 3% of the world's population. Half of them are women and 20% have no legal status.

“Asylum seekers and migrants in search of work are literally in the same boat,” Trygve G. Nordby, the International Federation’s Special Envoy on Migration and Displacement pointed out, in his address to representatives of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies currently attending the 7th European Regional Conference in Istanbul, Turkey. “Every day, week in and week out, our Red Cross colleagues in Spain and Italy help people in the worst imaginable state, out of the ocean. This is a humanitarian challenge as much as it is a political one.” Migration is one of the two major themes of the conference.

An increasing number of European Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies are providing migrants – in both regular and irregular situations – with food, shelter, health care and the possibility to contact their families. This support is based on people’s vulnerability and needs, regardless of their legal status.

The Federation’s Special Envoy, who has been analyzing the humanitarian consequences of migration, noted that these activities have drawn criticism and accusations that Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies, as well as other organizations such as the UNHCR and NGOs, are encouraging migratory flows by setting up reception structures and programmes for refugees, displaced people and irregular migrants.

He categorically refutes that argument: “People do not move, unless there is a good reason. War, conflict, political persecution, poverty and pure survival for themselves and their families make people move, seeking protection and livelihoods elsewhere. It is not the humanitarian assistance offered to these groups that make them flee or travel. For that matter, humanitarian organisations offer help and assistance to only a relatively small number of irregular migrants. I think it is indecent to suggest that people expose themselves to real danger for the hope for a free blanket, some food and humanitarian assistance.”

Mr. Nordby noted differences in Red Cross Red Crescent responses to the needs of vulnerable migrants. “Some National Societies give assistance to irregular migrants as auxiliaries to their governments, others go beyond and base their action on their humanitarian mandate. Sometimes they act without the approval of the government. We also see National Societies that choose not to give assistance to irregular migrants in fear of getting into conflict with the authorities,” he explained.

According to Trygve G. Nordby, it is essential that Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies define and strengthen their role and a common advocacy position on the question of migration, especially vis-à-vis their own government, during the current European conference. These recommendations will be submitted to the International Red Cross and Red Crescent Conference, which will bring together States, their National Societies and the ICRC, in Geneva next November.

In his opinion, irregular or unauthorised immigrants could be one of the most important groups of beneficiaries for Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies in the future.

The Special Envoy makes it clear that the International Federation recognizes that States have the right to determine their policy in relation to the situation of migrants. But, he adds, all migrants should be able to exercise their fundamental human rights. “We urge States to ratify and promote the implementation of the 1990 International Convention on the Protection of the Rights of All Migrant Workers and Members of their Families. We should challenge States to fight the reasons why people leave their homes to seek fortune elsewhere.”

People leave their native country for many, often interrelated reasons which all have to do with looking for a better life. Most move voluntarily, some are forced to flee, and some leave in extremely difficult situations, which endanger their life, or expose them to situations of acute vulnerability, such as exploitation, prostitution and human trafficking. As humanitarian actors advocating principles of humanity and impartiality, Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies cannot remain indifferent to these tragedies.
Trygve G. Nordby, the International Federation’s Special Envoy on Migration and Displacement. (p15765) (Photo: Ahmet Ors/Turkish Red Crescent)
Trygve G. Nordby, the International Federation’s Special Envoy on Migration and Displacement. (p15765) (Photo: Ahmet Ors/Turkish Red Crescent)
RELATED LINKS
VII European conference 2007
Read the article in Russian
More news stories
“Every day, week in and week out, our Red Cross colleagues in Spain and Italy help people in the worst imaginable state, out of the ocean. This is a humanitarian challenge as much as it is a political one.” “Asylum seekers and migrants in search of work are literally in the same boat,” pointed out Mr.Nordby. (Photo: Manuel Lérida/Spanish Red Cross)
“Every day, week in and week out, our Red Cross colleagues in Spain and Italy help people in the worst imaginable state, out of the ocean. This is a humanitarian challenge as much as it is a political one.” “Asylum seekers and migrants in search of work are literally in the same boat,” pointed out Mr.Nordby. (Photo: Manuel Lérida/Spanish Red Cross)