International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies (IFRC) International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies (IFRC)
Search :

News
News Home
News Stories
Press Releases
Speeches
Opinion Pieces
Audio & Video
A root and branch approach to disaster prevention in the Kyrgyz hills
17 January 2005
by John Sparrow in Kyrgyzstan; pictures by Eddy Posthuma de Boer
The 2,000 inhabitants of Kyzyl-Charba have to move. The hillside above them is going to collapse and a landslide will sweep away their village. Experts tell them it is safe for now but the danger is developing.

No one need look far to understand what that means. Up the road a hillside fell away last summer. Some six million cubic metres of mud roared over the road and blocked the nearby river. The Ministry of Ecology and Emergencies needed a month and a half to clear the road.

The river needed longer to clear itself.
Huge mud walls either side of the road are still a reminder to the villagers. But here in Osh province, and in neighbouring Jalal-Abad, in south-western Kyrgyzstan, they do not really need reminding. They have lived with disaster all their lives. The biggest problem is that they accept them - that disasters are almost no longer news.

Landslides, floods and debris flows are frequent, earthquakes common. Osh province had five major slides last year; Jalal-Abad suffered 44 disasters in the first quarter alone, according to the governor's office, and the annual average is 150 and increasing. The authorities primarily blame climate change, saying ever more rain saturates and undermines a relatively young geology, and swells river systems.

The Ministry of Emergencies has mapped 3,000 landslide-prone areas in Kyrgyzstan's mountainous south, and says 700 settlements are under some kind of disaster threat. The spring of 2003 underlined the warning with catastrophe affecting 4,000 people, flooding or destroying close to 400 homes, and badly damaging infrastructure.

Worst of all was the mudslide that overwhelmed the village of Sogot, in Osh province's Uzgen district. Of the 38 people who died when 1.5 million cubic metres of mud descended on the village, most were women and children, some of them mothers rushing back to their homes to save infants.

Sultan Akylov's wife was one of them. He lost a son and two daughters, as well. Away from the village herding livestock when the hillside fell, he returned to find his home buried. Today he lives with five surviving children in a new community of modern brick houses well away from any danger. A government scheme with interest-free loans and other forms of assistance is re-housing people from the most stricken and threatened areas.

The tragedy is that Akylov's loved ones need not have perished. A few years before, the government had distributed relocation money to entice people away from threatened communities. Villagers spent it on other things, and say now that they were too poor to move and had more pressing requirements: livestock, seeds, their children's education. Now the government is cracking down, obliging people to move to safety.

The flood-prone hamlet of Jilaldy in the Uzgen district is one where a move is underway. Jilaldy is located on low-lying land next to the Zerger river, and the swampy surrounds are perfect for rice, the main crop. What is good for rice is not necessarily good for people and when, last spring, snowmelt swelled the river, the bank gave way and the hamlet went under - as it has done periodically for as long as such things have been recorded.

Some villagers are already rehoused alongside the victims of Sogot, and the authorities plan to move the rest in 2004. Osh's civil defence chief, Jergalbek Isakeevich Ukashev, is being firm with people who try to retain their old homes after getting a new one somewhere else. "They can still use the land but once they have moved we tell them to destroy the old house or we will destroy it for them."

Getting those most at risk to safety will be a long process. Near Sogot, he points to the scar hanging over what remains of the village, then to telltale signs of other disasters developing in the highlands. Some 350 families still live here and over the next five years the authorities plan to re-house them all. Since most of them depend on cattle that need the highland pastures, they will be allowed to live here in summer. But, Ukashev says, when the weather turns and the landslide season approaches, they will be obliged to leave again.

Preventing disaster

Placing people out of harm's way is one method of avoiding calamity but in a country which is 93 per cent mountains, has 20 types of natural disaster and around a million people exposed to a high risk of earthquakes, avalanches, mudflows and landslides, it is one small part of the disaster prevention and preparedness equation. The Kyrgyzstan Red Crescent is helping communities to manage the risk and reduce the impact.

When emergencies happen, Red Crescent relief comes fast via a national network of branches and school programmes, by organizing local disaster committees, and by removing risk factors where possible, the same branches working to avert the human suffering they so often have to mitigate. Supported by the Netherlands Red Cross and the disaster preparedness programme of the European Commission's Humanitarian Aid Office (DIPECHO), they are showing vulnerable people that they are far from helpless.

The European Union provides about half of all the humanitarian aid spent on emergencies around the world. ECHO's core mandate is emergency aid but it has been financing disaster preparedness since 1996. Poul Nielson, European Commissioner for Development and Humanitarian Aid, affirms, "even simple and inexpensive precautions can help save lives and property when disaster strikes. Our preparedness programme has proved effective for beneficiaries and good value for European tax payers."

His words gain perspective in Jalal-Abad and Osh provinces, Kyrgyzstan's most disaster prone areas. Although the risk is high, a Dutch-supported Red Crescent branch development programme found communities unaware of, and unprepared for, events that could easily overwhelm them. Violeta Lombarts, Netherlands Red Cross desk officer for Central Asia, explains.

"There are very few roads in the rural areas and those are likely to be cut in the event of disaster, and even in urban and semi-urban areas little infrastructure exists for disaster response. Self-help is imperative so now with our help the Red Crescent is strengthening local capacities."

Salam-Alik, a village of seven hamlets surrounded by hills in deepest Osh, is far from any assistance and getting to it when disaster strikes could be problematic. Given the unstable hillsides, the annual mudflows and the recurring seismic tremors - some 42 registered in the first eight months of last year - a disaster could occur tomorrow. If it did, getting word out, or even round the village, would be challenging.

The one telephone line Salam-Alik possesses is out of order most of the time. "We would have to warn people by going around on horseback or sounding a gong," someone ventured at a village meeting.

Discussion about being prepared has preoccupied the village since the Red Crescent advised it to establish a local disaster committee. Now the community has been divided up into operational sectors and people assigned key functions.

Head teacher Salamat Jarkynbaeva has prepared an evacuation plan that she reviews and updates on a regular basis. Hospital nurse Saira Toktahunova can be seen out and about the village monitoring who is ill and where the babies are located: essential intelligence should emergency action be necessary.

Salam-Alik is developing a disaster plan so that if, God forbid, catastrophe strikes everyone will know what to do. The teacher and nurse are among a dozen leaders who have all formed groups to deal with specific issues. Jarkynbaeva is proud of her senior pupils who are ready to take care of the elderly. The Red Crescent is guiding and training the leaders. What they are taught of first aid and disaster preparedness they pass on to their people.

Disasters can also be prevented. Salam-Alik's economy is agriculture, cattle rearing and walnut growing. Some of the world's best walnuts come from here and it is the most common tree in the district. The Kyrgyzstan Red Crescent and the Netherlands Red Cross see more than nuts when they look at stands of walnut trees. They see roots with a spread of around six metres. Just what you need to bring stability to a potentially risky hillside.

With DIPECHO funding, they have acquired some 20,800 walnut trees to plant on unwooded hillsides above the village that, left untouched, could produce devastating landslides in the near future. Set five metres apart they will cover 220,000 square metres and between them will be planted acacia, dog rose and karagach trees. The root network produced will be as intricate and stable as the thick wire meshing that encases rock where the Red Crescent is strengthening river banks.

The people of Salam-Alik will take care of the trees. They will sleep safer in their beds at night and the harvest will put money in the community's pocket.

How many lives could be saved?

What would you do if there were an earthquake? The question from a Red Crescent officer brings an incredulous smile to the face of 14-year-old Ainura in the Jiyde village school in Jalal-Abad. The body language needs no translation. "Are you a fruit cake or what?" she is thinking and from the back of the classroom shouts, "Run! Run for your life, of course."
The officer begs to differ. "You'd be better advised to find a nice strong doorway," she tells her. "You might just be running to your
death."

Ainura stops grinning. "Huh?" she says, her eyes popping out of her head.
It is in the schools of Kyrgyzstan that the Red Crescent begins its disaster preparedness programmes. The children have to know. This session is an introduction but soon teachers will be trained to train their pupils themselves. First aid will be part of the programme.

The Jiyde school was chosen because the community sits by the Karadaria river and is prone to mud flows and flooding. Earthquakes have shaken it in the past, the biggest in 1992 when one registering six on the Richter scale caused considerable damage. The epicentre was 180 kilometres away.

No one died that day. "But imagine," the Red Crescent officer is telling a group of teachers gathered to discuss the programme. "It is nine o'clock in the morning, an earthquake occurs, the school collapses. How many lives could you have saved?"

If anyone doubted disaster preparedness was necessary, they do not doubt it now.
The local population plants trees in Salim Alik as a way of preventing landslides (p12492)
RELATED LINKS
Activities in Kyrgyzstan
Kobe special page
More news stories
A village in Dubitel region, abandoned after being destroyed in a flood (p12494)
Flood-affected villagers from Dubitel region have been re-housed in new homes in safer areas (p12491)
Local Red Crescent volunteers in Salam Alik region conduct an earthquake disaster exercise, raising awareness among the local population about what to do if disaster strikes (p12493)
Children take part in an evacuation exercise in Salam Alik (p12495)